A Sobering Examination of the Feasibility of Aqueous Aluminum Batteries

Schematic of the solvation environment of 3.6m Al(OTf)3-H2O and parasitic mechanisms, including: (a) proton activity, (b) octahedral coordination of H2O and transient OH- to Al3+, (c) hydrogen evolution, (d) corrosion, and (e) a lack of solid electrolyte interphase formation.

Scientific Achievement

We revealed the first compelling evidence for a dynamic octahedral solvation structure around Al3+ dominated by labile water and OH-, without Al-OTf contact ion pairs, at high salt concentrations. High proton activity is observed in transport and electrochemical measurements which relates well with the proposed solvation environment.


We also exposed practical concerns related to (i) the corrosiveness of the acidic aqueous solutions, (ii) the degree of hydration of Al(OTf)3 salt, and (iii) the grossly insufficient reductive stability (>1 V between HER onset and Al3+/Al). Collectively, these factors constitute multiple fundamental barriers to the feasibility of rechargeable aqueous Al batteries.


  • Glenn Pastel (ARL): Electrochemistry/Physicochemical
  • Ying Chen (PNNL): Liquid & solid-state NMR
  • Travis Pollard (ARL): Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics simulations
  • Allen Zheng (Hunter College): PFG-NMR (diffusivity)
  • Nathan Hahn (Sandia): Dielectric Relaxation Spectroscopy

Download this highlight

DOI: 10.1039/D2EE00134A

Latest Updates

See All
  • JCESR Spotlight: Bob Jin Kwon, A Postdoc with Passion and Perseverance

    Argonne recognizes Kwon’s contributions to battery science with the Postdoctoral Performance Award. Article authored by: Michael Matz, Argonne Associate Bob Jin Kwon likes a good challenge, particularly when it comes to developing completely new kinds of batteries. “Developing new battery technologies is very challenging,” said … Read More

  • JCESR Spotlight: Lily Robertson Recognized for Her Contributions to Battery Research

    Argonne’s Postdoctoral Performance Award recognizes scientific achievements, leadership, and collaboration. Article authored by: Michael Matz, Argonne Associate Since her early days growing up in the Pacific Northwest, Lily Robertson has always wanted to help make the world a better place. “For as … Read More

  • Understanding fluorine-free electrolytes via small-angle X-ray scattering

    We compare the solvation phenomenon of sodium tetraphenylborate (NaBPh4) salt dissolved in organic solvents of propylene carbonate (PC), 1,2-dimethoxyethane (DME), acetonitrile (ACN) and tetrahydrofuran (THF) by SAXS/WAXS measurement and MD simulation. Read More

  • Navigating the Minefield of Battery Literature

    This is an invited perspective aiming to help researchers new to the field of battery research to circumvent certain recurring misconceptions and inaccuracies in the current battery literature. It covers the electrolyte ideality and practical situation in batteries, the difficulty in accurately determining ion transference … Read More

  • Quantifying Lithium Ion Exchange in Solid Electrolyte Interphase (SEI) on Graphite Anode Surfaces

    By using Li isotopic labelling of SEIs and electrolytes followed by time-of-flight secondary-ion mass spectroscopy and solid-state NMR analyses, we found that the majority of Li+ “immobilized” in the chemical ingredients were exchanged after 1 SEI formation cycle. Ion exchange by diffusion based on concentration … Read More